SFMTA ISCOTT Hearing – Hayes Street Closure Renewal

November 10, 2026
Dear ISCOTT Members,

The Hayes Valley Small Business Association (HVSBA) opposes the proposed two-year renewal of the recurring closure of the 400 block of Hayes Street.

Hayes Street is an established commercial corridor whose businesses depend on reliable customer access, deliveries, loading, transportation, and the everyday circulation of residents and visitors. For six years, the recurring closure has altered those conditions, yet the City continues to consider successive renewals without adequately addressing the concerns raised by independent merchants.

The proposed two-year authorization is particularly troubling. What began as a temporary arrangement in 2020 would now extend through November 2028, without a demonstrated need to maintain the closure or a clear explanation of why reopening Hayes Street is not a reasonable alternative.

These concerns have become more consequential as Hayes Valley accommodates additional programmed activities, including the Farmers Market and Entertainment Zone. The cumulative effects on the commercial corridor deserve serious consideration, particularly amid continued retail turnover and ongoing concerns about business access.

HVSBA supports a vibrant Hayes Valley and opportunities for neighborhood events. But supporting events is not the same as supporting a recurring street closure. Existing public spaces and individually permitted events provide alternatives that do not require Hayes Street to remain closed week after week.

We urge SFMTA to decline the proposed two-year renewal, restore Hayes Street to ordinary circulation, and give the needs of the commercial corridor the consideration they deserve.

Best,
Hayes Valley Small Business Association (HVSBA)