June 24, 2025
Attention Board of Supervisors
We write again to express our urgent opposition to the proposed designation of Hayes Valley as an Entertainment Zone.
This legislation was introduced without notice, transparency, or meaningful engagement with the small businesses that keep this corridor functioning. Many of our members among the longest-standing independent operators in the neighborhood are already struggling under a weekend street closure that was supposed to be temporary. Quality foot traffic has declined, longtime customers avoid the area, and ongoing event programming continues to divert attention away from local commerce. Now, this amendment seeks to make those harms permanent – with no consultation and no recourse.
Let us be clear: Hayes Valley is not a nightlife district. It is a mixed-use neighborhood of residents, families, and storefront businesses. To designate 20 blocks as a permanent Entertainment Zone favoring a destination-driven bar economy is simply reckless. It disregards the decades of investment and community-building that define this corridor.
What’s most disturbing is that this ordinance would deepen an already polarizing situation. The street closure remains divisive and unresolved …a failed experiment that a broad plurality of residents and merchants have been working in good faith to end. Rather than address these concerns, this legislation sidesteps them entirely and seeks to entrench the closure through an even more expansive, permanent framework. We’ve already seen how this plays out. The street closure permit has no enforcement, no compliance standards, and no consequences for ongoing violations. Now, the same entity behind that closure (HVNA) is poised to manage the Entertainment Zone. We expect more of the same: no accountability, no transparency, and no regard for impacted businesses.
It must also be said: to blindly defer to the district Supervisor is not leadership — it’s abdication. The Board may assume Supervisor Mahmood has conducted broad outreach. He has not. Our only meeting with him, in March, ended abruptly after we clearly stated that an Entertainment Zone would be devastating to our businesses. There was no follow-up, no further contact. What followed instead was a staged press event, orchestrated with those already aligned with his agenda. This is not consensus. It is manufactured alignment in the face of broad contradiction. Why is HVNA, a self-appointed gatekeeper being elevated, while the true plurality of neighborhood voices is ignored? Why are bars and nightlife operators being given a free hand to reshape a corridor they do not represent? What’s happening here reflects a pattern born out of COVID — a hollowing out of public process. Input became selectively crafted. Dialogue became scripted. That same playbook is being used here in Hayes Valley again, in a dangerous and exclusionary way — and our businesses are being forced to carry the cost.
We urge the Board to act: Remove Hayes Valley from this ordinance. Without a Supervisor who is willing to defend the full spectrum of community voices, we are at a profound disadvantage. Please do not codify that disadvantage into law.
Sincerely,
HVSBA